0:00
Essentially, it's a philosophy book.
0:01
Kahlil Gibran, he is calling himself in
0:05
this like or or he has a character in
0:07
there. It's like you know, he's calling
0:09
the prophet. One day he had to leave the
0:12
to the city and look at the philosophy
0:14
on various topics. Your children are not
0:17
your children. They are the sons and
0:20
daughters of life's longing for itself.
0:23
They come through you but not from you.
0:26
Throughout this book, I think he has
0:27
never called upon something a God or
0:30
anything like that because I think he
0:32
wanted to be more inclusive of everyone.
0:34
But you can see the usage of the like
0:37
you know, the he and the his like you
0:39
know, it's it's capital H capital H for
0:42
his capital H for he. It's presenting
0:44
like you know, that godly figure or the
0:46
divine figure or or or he's calling just
0:52
No, it's it's a it's a it's an idea.
0:55
It's it's more of a what you want it to
0:58
be. In real life, does it does it
1:00
translate into a real life situations?
1:02
Like I don't know because think about
1:04
this. He says, you may give them your
1:06
love but not your thoughts. What else do
1:09
you pass out pass to your children?
1:11
Don't you pass your values? Don't you
1:12
pass your like certain infrastructure
1:15
like you know, structure to their life
1:17
that hey, this is a good thing. This is
1:19
a bad thing. For even as he loves the
1:20
arrow that flies, so he loves also the
1:26
actually classy value a good thing to
2:09
You got a mustache, too.
2:12
>> The prophet Kahlil Gibran, yes.
2:20
from this very famous book that I know
2:23
you have also read and you brought this
2:39
Kahlil Gibran because this is one of my
2:49
>> Well, they actually then your book is
2:53
as compared to mine. Look at this. I got
2:55
a pocket size version of You got a
2:57
pocket size cuz I mean you you might
2:59
need a pocket size version
3:03
and you can like open it up for any
3:04
topic, any situation that you're in.
3:07
And it could be like a guide book. I
3:08
mean, I think that's that's the idea.
3:10
Like do you want to explain what the
3:11
premise of this book is a little bit? I
3:14
mean, yeah. It's it's a
3:18
Essentially, it's a philosophy book like
3:21
this Kahlil Gibran, he is calling
3:26
himself in this like or or he has a
3:29
character in there. It's like you know,
3:31
he's calling the prophet essentially and
3:47
look at the philosophy
3:48
on various topics. So this book is is a
3:51
collection of 26 poems
3:56
essentially on different topics of what
3:58
he thinks about those topics, right?
4:15
philosophy. We should
4:16
cover that one as well at some point.
4:24
that we going to cover today.
4:29
to deliver his own philosophy but
4:32
through a character named I think Al
4:39
portrayed as the prophet in this
4:41
fictional in this fictional story.
4:49
illustrations that the author did that
4:51
Kahlil Gibran did. I think he did about
4:54
12 illustrations and one of them
4:58
actually the one that we want to cover.
5:00
I think we'll end up covering a couple
5:01
of them. But you on children
5:12
I think we should show it first and then
5:14
we should read it so it will make sense.
5:15
Like it it essentially opens up to the
5:20
I think so. Or should we should do
5:21
should we do it at the end?
5:23
I think we should do it at the end
5:26
it ends on that note. Okay. And I mean,
5:30
you know, it ends on that note and then
5:32
it makes sense. So I mean, sure. But
5:35
that's the thing, right? Like
5:45
I'm not going to explain anything there,
5:47
right? You know, just look at it.
5:48
Someone's holding a bow like you know,
5:51
to shoot an arrow. That's all I see
5:53
right now. Yeah, it's it's not like a
5:55
conventional type bow, though. Yes.
5:57
Yeah, so that's what we going to find
5:58
out in the poem itself. So let me read
6:00
that. It's it's a whimsical drawing of a
6:05
I'll just leave it at that.
6:11
the way the poem goes is essentially a
6:13
woman who is holding her
6:16
baby and she asking the prophet Al
6:19
Mustafa, speak to us of children. Yeah,
6:23
I imagined her yelling.
6:25
Yes, speak to her. Cuz cuz the prophet
6:28
is standing up there like that on the
6:30
ship and she she's she's clutching a
6:35
how? Speak to us Speak to us of
6:37
children. What about the children?
6:40
I don't know. For some reason I always
6:42
imagine this Italian like I always go
6:46
>> Speak to us of children.
6:50
in my head. All right. So it says
6:53
Okay, hold on. Let me look at the camera
6:55
while I say this one.
7:01
Your children are not your children.
7:04
They are the sons and daughters of
7:07
life's long for its longing for itself.
7:11
They come through you but not from you.
7:15
And though they are with you, yet they
7:22
You may give them your love but not your
7:25
thoughts. For they have their own
7:29
You may house their bodies but not their
7:33
For their souls dwell in the house of
7:37
Which you cannot visit not even in your
7:42
You may strive to be like them
7:45
but seek not to make them like you.
7:49
For life goes not backwards not tarries
7:55
You are the bows from which your
7:58
children as living arrows are sent
8:03
The archer sees the mark upon the path
8:09
And he bends you with his might and his
8:12
arrows may go swift and far.
8:16
Let your bending in the archer's hand be
8:20
For even as he loves the arrow that
8:24
so he loves also the bow that is stable.
8:33
For even as he loves the arrow that
8:34
flies, so he loves also the bow that is
8:37
Yeah, but that is stable.
8:52
And and and now please bring back the
8:55
illustration that you were showing
8:56
because I feel like now it will make
8:58
more sense and and now we can even see
9:00
the bow that it actually makes made out
9:05
Not very clear but I think yeah, I think
9:08
it's blurry but it's essentially made
9:10
out of two people which I'm assuming men
9:12
and women at that time
9:14
when it's written. But the stability, it
9:16
comes from both joining their hands
9:19
essentially coming together
9:21
in the hands of this mighty being which
9:27
like Al Mustafa is calling life. But if
9:31
like in the poem itself, it's capital L.
9:35
Life's longing for itself. So when when
9:38
you use capital L like that within the
9:40
middle of the sentence and like you
9:41
know, so so it throughout this book, I
9:43
think he has never called upon
9:46
something a God or anything like that
9:48
because I think he wanted to be more
9:50
inclusive of everyone. But but you can
9:55
the the usage of the like you know the
9:58
he and the his like you know it's it's
10:01
capital H capital H for his capital H
10:04
for he it it's it's presenting like you
10:08
know that that godly figure or the
10:09
divine figure or or or he's calling just
10:12
life. Like you know like he's just
10:14
calling that life or
10:16
so I [clears throat] I think I think
10:18
this book is without
10:21
without using religion
10:24
he's communicating what mostly all
10:26
religions communicate and and and point
10:32
I don't want to give religion that much
10:36
religion like you know it's it's still
10:40
Religion has too many
10:43
I would say this I would say this when
10:45
the religion started they were not going
10:47
to be like you know they were not trying
10:48
to be a religion they were just trying
10:50
to put out the philosophies and exactly
10:52
what he's doing right now. Like you know
10:53
they they believed in certain things and
10:55
they like you know went for those right
10:57
like you know they wrote those down and
10:58
everything. What I don't like about
11:01
religion and everything in that context
11:03
is it's too like you know becomes
11:05
regimentation over time. I mean that's
11:07
how that's how people interpret it as
11:10
like but what I'm saying is at the core
11:12
Yeah. the religions of the world the
11:15
major religions of the world
11:17
are communicating these type of values
11:19
and I'm not going into the religion
11:21
piece of it what I'm saying is the
11:27
is without bringing religion into it.
11:30
But he did bring religion into it in one
11:32
sense because he's calling him the
11:33
prophet so he's not going into the
11:35
rituals of it. I mean is it religion
11:37
though like you know I mean it's it's
11:40
like the god and the prophet can very
11:43
well exist outside of any religion as
11:46
Right so so because you're looking from
11:48
the religious lens what if like just say
11:51
it was written even any if any religion
11:54
like before any religion that existed on
11:57
earth or like any ideas that were talked
11:58
about in that sense right calling
12:00
himself the prophet or anything that
12:01
does not mean it's a religion he can
12:04
just talk about god or
12:05
>> I correlate prophet with the religion
12:08
>> There you go that's what I'm saying
12:10
because the bias is there right that's
12:11
>> people do most people do. Sure sure but
12:14
but that's the thing you I I think it's
12:17
just a like you know I'll take him as a
12:21
and understand it as such because to be
12:23
honest like But but the book is not
12:25
called the philosopher it's called the
12:29
undeniably there is a religious not
12:32
religious angle to it but he's
12:34
communicating basically what he's
12:36
communicating in this book is that
12:37
religion teaches you all this without
12:39
without going into a particular type of
12:41
religion or staying away from the
12:43
politics of religions.
12:46
personally I fail to see it still but
12:50
because also I'm going to say that
12:53
I'm not sure if I agree with this I'm
12:55
not sure if I agree with this poem like
12:57
because I think about it a lot. And
13:00
like sometimes it feels like you know
13:03
there's there's a concept called first
13:06
of all I don't think he had children or
13:08
he ever took care of his children or if
13:09
he had any. Why why do you say that?
13:12
Because I think I read up somewhere that
13:16
and we can check that. Kahlil Gibran had
13:19
>> saying this whole poem is false like No
13:21
it's it's a it's a it's an idea it's
13:25
it's more of a what you want it to be.
13:29
In real life does it does it translate
13:31
into a real life situations like I don't
13:34
know because because think about this
13:36
think about this right? He says
13:39
you may give them your love but not your
13:41
thoughts. Okay I also have a problem
13:43
with that piece like thoughts I also
13:44
have a problem with that piece like
13:48
I mean what what else are you going to
13:50
do not exist like because if they are
13:52
around you they going to get your
13:53
thoughts and what else do you pass out
13:56
pass to your children don't you pass
13:58
your values don't you pass your like
14:00
certain infrastructure like you know
14:02
structure to their life that hey this is
14:04
a good thing this is a bad thing like
14:06
you know you give them some idea but
14:08
according to this one it just feels like
14:10
there's no structure whatsoever you just
14:15
Right so so it's the autonomy of the
14:18
kids while they're not even aware what
14:21
life actually means we don't know either
14:24
but we at least more would know more
14:25
than them in that sense right?
14:30
to what extent like there's there's no
14:35
it's it's too vague it's too vague.
14:42
But but I I still don't think like you
14:44
know I don't agree with it in that sense
14:46
>> I I I agree with that part in the sense
14:49
that I disagree with you may give them
14:51
your love but not your thoughts. I know
14:52
what they're going for but yeah there's
14:54
there's there needs to be a little bit
14:56
more clarity but do you agree with
14:58
you may house their bodies but not their
15:02
so so let me let me give you an example
15:04
like what I thought of was first time I
15:07
While I was reading it I was like you
15:11
Like during the same time or something I
15:14
I think I recently found out about
15:16
something called as lighthouse
15:18
Lighthouse parenting essentially means
15:22
like you know what it sounds like you
15:24
know and it it actually comes close to
15:26
what what he's saying is you are
15:29
essentially a lighthouse in the middle
15:32
of the ocean like you know on island or
15:34
something and your kids are essentially
15:36
a ship out in the ocean right? They can
15:39
always look back to you for direction of
15:41
where they are in the ocean if they are
15:44
Right? But you don't have any control
15:49
managing themselves in the ocean. Yeah.
15:53
That just means that that's just from
15:56
the name right? But the the the whole
15:59
the whole concept of lighthouse
16:01
parenting came from a pediatrician
16:02
actually and she actually had kids and
16:05
she managed her own like you know took
16:07
care of her kids and everything so
16:10
reading more into it
16:13
like on the surface it looks like he's
16:15
saying the same thing
16:16
but when you go into depth into
16:18
lighthouse parenting you understand that
16:19
no there's still a structure there is a
16:22
still like you know certain kind of like
16:24
you know the the principle or the values
16:26
that you create around them. So for
16:28
example for example right? And I think
16:31
it will come back to this again
16:33
when I give that example right?
16:35
In lighthouse parenting I think there
16:40
um like let just say your kid tomorrow
16:43
like you know they get their heart
16:44
broken or they like you know lose a race
16:47
or something and they're like feel
16:48
defeated and like you know they're not
16:52
up to like you know like
16:55
essentially they're not feeling well um
17:01
sitting in a dark room like you know
17:03
thinking it over and everything. Now
17:06
is your job and metaphorically and
17:09
literally is your job to go turn on that
17:13
or your job is to go sit with them in
17:16
the dark while they figure out what's
17:20
Right? And think about this while he
17:24
you may give them your love but not your
17:26
thoughts. So while you are sitting with
17:29
them in that dark room you're giving
17:31
them your love your support but you're
17:33
not giving them your thoughts.
17:35
You're not giving them how to deal with
17:38
it you're letting them deal with it but
17:40
you are in that like you're just
17:42
providing support with you're not fixing
17:44
the problem for them you're being with
17:46
them in the problem. Yeah. And there's a
17:48
difference there right? So so I think
17:53
like when I first read it I didn't agree
17:55
with it but then I read the lighthouse
17:57
parenting and then I came back to it and
17:58
I was just like oh that makes sense if
18:00
we go in certain details and try to
18:02
understand it a little bit.
18:04
>> certain scenarios this makes sense. Yes
18:07
yeah yeah yeah yeah like certain things
18:09
like you know yeah if you just like
18:10
don't give them your thoughts whatsoever
18:12
like you know like your kid is like you
18:15
beating someone up in the street and you
18:16
can't even tell them that hey dude don't
18:18
do that like that's that's bully
18:20
behavior and that's not okay right?
18:23
Then that's not okay like you have to
18:25
give them your thoughts of like how you
18:26
feel about it and they shouldn't be
18:28
doing that to other kids you know. So so
18:31
yes in certain scenarios it it makes
18:33
sense. Yeah but I think that's a given
18:35
I think that's a given.
18:37
What is a given? Like that type of like
18:40
this is not telling you like what what
18:42
the baseline of parenting is. This is
18:45
No but I think the biggest problem is
18:48
that like is is parents trying to fix
18:50
the problem of the kids for the kids you
18:52
know and and because
18:55
somehow they have taken the
18:58
role of an entertainer in their life
19:01
where it's their job that when they're
19:03
sad it's somehow parents is job to cheer
19:08
instead of teaching the kid how to cheer
19:10
themselves up because it's going to take
19:12
time what it's going to take time like
19:14
you know the the the process. Right?
19:19
And you can like you know make an effort
19:26
You know like you have to go sit with
19:28
them support them listen to and and I'm
19:31
not talking out of like you know just
19:34
thin air like I've spoken to parents
19:37
try to understand different parenting
19:39
styles to to see how do they manage it
19:43
like you know how do they manage the
19:44
first heartbreak or or or like you know
19:47
failing an exam or like something they
19:50
They worked hard for and didn't make it,
19:52
you know. Um how? And also
19:56
again, how you manage it. Like, you
19:58
know, because they're going to learn
19:59
from you as well. Like, you know, you're
20:00
going to have a bad day. Uh when do you
20:02
when you come home after a bad day, how
20:07
Uh that's going to give them some
20:08
guidance. So, um even without you saying
20:12
anything, even without you telling them
20:15
either I would have thought of my case
20:16
say I'm dealing with it, right? Like,
20:18
it's not that. It's just observing you.
20:21
Yeah. In your day-to-day life, right?
20:31
>> But, uh but that stability part though,
20:33
I I actually this that's like you said
20:35
that key well, a client only
20:38
well, heavy well, yeah. Uh like I think
20:41
the the whole parenting is in that one
20:43
line. Yeah. Is that that you have to be
20:45
that stable bow. You have to be that
20:47
stable bow for them to go far.
20:50
Yeah. It It wouldn't have to be that
20:53
you have to have a good interview
20:55
and say you can say I think about taking
20:58
a new one or not but
21:00
essentially conservative values and the
21:02
rebel that you get rebellion that you
21:04
get against them. Like, you know, how
21:06
does it work? Like, you know, that why
21:08
is it necessary? So, so he said that
21:11
they're both necessary in the society in
21:13
the in the context of key
21:24
yeah, like you know,
21:26
whatever. Yeah, exactly. Cowboy style,
21:30
Who's that guy go? Who's that guy go
21:32
somewhere to go conservative values of
21:34
society or would you put that rebellion?
21:39
You need both of them.
21:43
to rather to rather have you have to
21:44
have to have to have to have to have to
21:46
have to have to have to have to have to
21:47
have to have to have to have to have to
21:47
have to have to have to have to have to
21:49
You need both of them. Been a rebellion
21:53
with that guy with that guy with that
21:54
guy with that guy with that guy with
21:55
that guy with that guy with that guy
21:56
with that guy with that guy with that
21:57
guy with that guy with that guy with
21:58
that guy with that guy with that guy
21:59
with that guy with that guy
22:01
And at the same time, without that
22:05
that but that that rock is going to fly
22:07
away Yeah. without any control. Yeah.
22:10
Right? It's a push and pull.
22:12
The way it works is like, you know, you
22:14
have the rotation and you let loose
22:17
every single rotation. You let loose a
22:19
little bit. You lose it. It goes further
22:21
and further and further, Yeah. You trust
22:24
the thread to bring it back. Exactly.
22:53
Yep. And and and that's what we
22:55
understand the society overall, right?
22:57
Like, you know, I'm getting to think
22:58
that you look at the society
23:00
conservative values or rebellion or
23:02
up left is right is you be a but but
23:04
they're both important to the um
23:09
to to make the society and balance it
23:12
Um right now, we're living in extremes.
23:14
So, I don't know how the
23:15
how the society is going to balance
23:17
itself out but at some point it will, I
23:23
Yeah. Yeah. That's what they keep saying
23:25
and that's what I'm holding on to but
23:29
yeah, we we come back to some saner or
23:45
We're going to let you guys guess in the
23:47
we're not going to explicitly say it.
23:49
But when we we're calling out for
23:51
sanity, it means we are on the other
23:52
side right now, right? So, obviously.
23:56
Yeah. But um but yeah, that was actually
23:58
I think a wonderful poem to cover. Yeah,
24:01
and a great book to read. There's other
24:03
topics in here. I would
24:04
you know, recommend our listeners and
24:08
viewers to go check it out. It's a very
24:10
small book. It's probably the easiest
24:12
book to read cuz you can pick up a
24:16
I I sit with it. Like, easier in the
24:18
sense that to read, yes, but you have to
24:21
sit with that chapter. Like, I I have I
24:23
still haven't finished it. Uh
24:31
because I want to sit with that poem and
24:33
I want to like let it settle in. Yeah.
24:36
Then it's kind of it's my just say
24:38
second Joe favorite hair.
24:40
I think it that's became the first
24:42
favorite. I think it's it's called
24:43
reason and passion. I'm trying to find
24:45
it. But but check that one out as well
24:47
and I think we should cover it.
24:57
you know, like this whole divinity to
25:00
how your reasons and your passions are
25:01
like your logic and your your you know,
25:10
passion and how you can say
25:12
balance out that the circle of how you
25:14
can use use that to you.
25:18
Do you want to read it or do we do it in
25:19
another episode? No, another episode.
25:21
Like, that one needs yeah, reason and
25:23
passion. Yeah, that one needs its own
25:33
that's very good. I'm excited. We should
25:34
do more. I think there's 26 of them in
25:36
here and we can even find more
25:41
and bring some more.
25:43
Well, thank you, everyone. Thank you.