The Daily TLDR

Saturday, June 7, 2025

Back to Headlines

When Does US National Debt Become a Crisis?

wsj, June 6, 2025

When Does US National Debt Become a Crisis?

The video kicks off by recounting a shocking event after a big tariff announcement: the value of the dollar dropped, a first in recent memory. Usually, in market turmoil, investors flock to the US for safety, boosting the dollar. This unexpected flight from the US signaled a deep-seated nervousness about US assets, linked directly to the spiraling national debt and subsequent credit rating downgrade. This moment was a wake-up call about the debt's serious implications.

So, what exactly is the national debt? It's simply the accumulation of budget deficits over time, meaning Congress spends more than it collects in taxes. We've been running deficits for 20 years, with 2020 adding a whopping $1.8 trillion! To put it in perspective, the debt-to-GDP ratio is at World War II levels, but without the wartime justification.

While some government debt is good (providing low-risk assets, enabling borrowing during crises like pandemics), the sheer size of the current debt is concerning. Why? Firstly, every dollar the government borrows is a dollar not invested in productive corporate equity or savings accounts, which could otherwise boost economic productivity and individual incomes. Studies suggest fixing the debt could lead to nearly 7% larger incomes per person by 2050! Secondly, a massive chunk of the federal budget now goes to interest payments on previous debt—more than military spending or other government operations. It's like using a new credit card to pay off an old one, a tell-tale sign of financial trouble. A mere 1% rise in interest rates could add $300 billion in borrowing annually.

When does this debt become truly unsustainable? Experts warn that if publicly held debt surpasses 175-200% of GDP, it's a "drop dead limit." This leads to a "Greek-Portugal meltdown scenario" where an economy in distress can't tax enough to pay interest, interest rates skyrocket, and a severe recession hits. The kicker? This unraveling can happen swiftly, the moment capital markets lose faith in the US's ability to manage its finances. If investors demand higher interest rates on US securities, it ripples through the entire economy, hiking mortgages and corporate bonds, potentially spiraling into a devastating fiscal crisis.

So, how do we fix it? The idea of simply "growing our way out" is dismissed because current spending is already tied to economic growth. The consensus is clear: Congress must spend less and bring in more. This means tackling tough issues like Social Security and Medicare insolvency, reforming welfare and defense spending, implementing discretionary spending caps, and yes, raising taxes. It requires a "grand bargain" where "everything's on the table." The debt isn't a problem until "it suddenly is," and experts urge proactive solutions rather than waiting to find out how long the world will wait.

In essence, the national debt is a silent, insidious threat to our economic future, affecting everything from investment opportunities to your mortgage rates. Ignoring it isn't an option.