The Daily TLDR

Monday, November 17, 2025

Back to Headlines

UK's Controversial New Immigration Plan & Labour's Internal Turmoil

BBCNews, November 16, 2025

UK's Controversial New Immigration Plan & Labour's Internal Turmoil

The UK government, grappling with persistent public anxiety over immigration and past unfulfilled pledges like Rishi Sunak's "stop the boats," has unveiled a controversial new immigration plan spearheaded by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood. Touted as the most significant overhaul since World War II, the plan aims to "restore order and control" and reduce arrivals while increasing removals, arguing the current system is "out of control" and "dividing the country."

Key changes include:

  • A 20-year wait for asylum seekers to apply for permanent settled status, a quadrupling of the current 5-year period.
  • Regular reviews of refugee status every two and a half years. If a refugee's country of origin is deemed safe, they will be returned, regardless of how long they've been in the UK or if they've started a family. This principle would even apply to Ukrainians once the war ends.
  • The introduction of new, capped "safe routes" for genuine refugees, though details are pending and contingent on border security.

The proposals have ignited significant debate and criticism. Concerns range from the potential for increased bureaucracy (an estimated 67,000 additional checks for the Home Office), to the risk of forcing vulnerable asylum seekers into destitution by cutting accommodation and subsistence payments for those who break rules or commit crimes. Economically, questions are raised about the UK's reliance on immigrant labor in critical sectors like healthcare and hospitality, and whether economically inactive UK citizens can fill these roles.

Beyond the immigration policy, the discussion also delved into the palpable internal tensions within the Labour Party, despite their recent "incredible majority." Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood's surprisingly "punchier" rhetoric on immigration, echoing language traditionally associated with the Conservatives, signals a significant shift in Labour's stance. Furthermore, Mahmood publicly lambasted "horribly embarrassing" and "mortifying" briefings from Downing Street, calling for accountability from those responsible for internal leaks.

This public display of disunity, with senior figures like Wes Streeting and Ed Miliband also caught in the crossfire, has fueled speculation about Labour's leadership. Respected figures like David Blunkett suggest Keir Starmer has a limited window (three months) to assert control. The political drama is intensifying, with figures like Angela Rayner making strategic public appearances and Wes Streeting seemingly emerging stronger from the recent briefing debacle, even as the party grapples with the "bonkers" reality of leadership discussions so soon after a major victory.